living where he chose and keeping company with cultural icons of Furthermore, we will discuss the significance of the dominant art movement Manet was involved in during his art career, which was Realism and then Impressionism. And is Olympia actually emblematic of the male gazedoes she exists as a morsel to be devoured by the public or is she the one devouring us? empty themselves and become hollow It is believed that Manet depicted this woman as a French prostitute. [8], Though Manet's The Luncheon on the Grass (Le djeuner sur l'herbe) sparked controversy in 1863, his Olympia stirred an even bigger uproar when it was first exhibited at the 1865 Paris Salon. Olympia is a painting by douard Manet, first exhibited at the 1865 Paris Salon, which shows a nude woman ("Olympia") lying on a bed being brought flowers by a servant. Her artistic work was also shown in the Salon in Paris, where it was accepted on multiple occasions. During this time there was a developing art movement called Realism, which centered around art depicting everyday life and not so much subject matter (such as Biblical and mythological) that was far removed from what the modern-day person was experiencing. The subject of the work This provocative painting helped establish Manet as one of the most influential artists on the 19th-century French art scene. With her left she conceals her ambush. French painter douard Manet (1832-1883), one of the originators of Impressionism, was known during his lifetime for painting portraits, marine landscapes, still lifes, and scenes of Parisian life with a unique style of brisk strokes. This dissertation will attempt to provide a sustained art-historical treatment of the second figure, the prostitute's black maid, posed by a model whose name, as recorded by Manet, was Laure. In Lorraine O'Grady's essay titled "Olympia's Maid: Reclaiming Black Female Subjectivity",[15] she asserts, "Olympia's maid, like all other 'peripheral Negroes'", is a robot conveniently made to disappear into the background drapery. She posed as a bullfighter for him and also for the Dejeuner sur l'Herbe of 1862-63. The Salon was a prestigious event and attracted scholars, art dealers, collectors, and art patrons. A detail of A detail from Olympia (1863) by douard Manet, showing the loose brush strokes used by the artist; douard Manet, Public domain, via Wikimedia Commons. Furthermore, the vertical line from the curtain behind Venus directly lines up with her genital area, placing more focus on that area as noted, this is slightly off-center in Manets Olympia. Her brunette hair is tied back and almost blends in with the darker wall colors behind her. A fine red threadline, where the head Her role in Manets Olympia has been critiqued as being a peripheral negro and robot by the American writer and artist Lorraine OGrady. It asserts that it is only when the bi-figural significance of Manet's Olympia is recognized that the extent and influence of Manet's radical modernity can be most fully understood. Paul Gauguin, Copy of Manet's Olympia, 1891, oil on canvas, 89 x 130 cm (private collection) He was keen to shock the bourgeoisie and certainly his own nude in The Spirit of the Dead Watching "a slightly indecent study" as he described itis in many ways as radical as Manet's. The body is awkwardly positioned and disproportionate. Required fields are marked *. Olympia is a painting by douard Manet, first exhibited at the 1865 Paris Salon, which shows a nude woman ("Olympia") lying on a bed being brought flowers by a servant. However, from 1725 the Salon started exhibitions in the Louvre, mentioned above, and its name changed to Salon de Paris. When Edouard Manet's painting Olympia is hung in the Salon of . Shoes but not stockings, how sinister. What is at stake is an art-historical discourse posed as an intervention with the prevailing historical silence about the representation and legacy of Manet's Laure, and by derivation about the significance of the black female muse to the formation of modernism. When Olympia was exhibited at the Salone a part of Astrucs poem was included for the paintings catalog entry. I do not mean the symbol Her left hand (our right) is placed over her genital area, her fingers resting on the top of her right upper thigh. Victorine-Louise Meurent, a French model and artist, was the femlae reclining, who became known as Manet's Olympia. Remedia Amoris . Folio Society edition of Sternes Tristram Shandy. This did not stop him from winning a spot in the Salons exhibition, even after so many ridiculed his painting. Importantly, the audience who saw this painting consisted mainly of men who were educated and in elitist circles, especially the Salon. This is no morsel. Was he trying to produce a Furthermore, OGrady states that the maid is made to disappear into the background drapery. I suggest that you look at the work of The Met curator Denise Murrell. The caf concerts were a great symbol of these changes - a place where men and women from varying levels of society were able to mingle, enjoying company, drinks, and entertainment. Manet reworked Giorgione's The Sleeping Venus (c. 1510) and Titian's Venus of Urbino (c. 1538) in creating Olympia. Could the cat be depicted as either getting up from sleeping or about to lie down? Art Analysis: Manet's Olympia. An emerald velvet curtain is pulled back to reveal Olympiaa name commonly used by prostitutes at the timereclining on a bed facing the viewer while a black female servant presents her with a large bouquet of flowers and a black cat stands at her feet. What shocked contemporary audiences was not Olympia's nudity, nor the presence of her fully clothed maid, but her confrontational gaze and a number of details identifying her as a demi-mondaine or prostitute. They come to stare and also to be stared at by her commanding eyes. upon the giant tortoises. and a day job. Get the latest information and tips about everything Art with our bi-weekly newsletter. And it always will. 1865. The reasoning was odd, but the result was the sameOlympia became infamous and the painting had to be hung very high to protect it from physical attacks. The dissertation thereby suggests a continuing iconographic lineage for Manet's Laure, as manifested in iteratively modernizing depictions of the black female figure from 1870 to the present. Olympia Manet Analysis. 5 Pages. year, it elicited a similarly negative response from the masses. to the loosened mind, to the black. [3] Whereas the left hand of Titian's Venus is curled and appears to entice, Olympia's left hand appears to block, which has been interpreted as symbolic of her role as a prostitute, granting or restricting access to her body in return for payment. From 1850 up to 1856 he started studying under Thomas Couture, who was a French teacher and artist. The next genre was Portraiture and then Genre Paintings, which depicted everyday scenes and were also smaller in size. I find it incredibly intriguing, so much so, I am choosing to study it as a related text for my postmodernism course. Holding prostitute. These darker shades of colors from the background emphasize the foreground, placing most of the attention on the lighter whites from Olympia and her bedding. Take a look at ourOlympiaby Manet webstory here! Olympia was a modern woman of life who was aware of the strength of her body, daring and self-confident. Giorgione, Sleeping Venus (c. 1510), also known as the Dresden Venus, Francisco de Goya, La maja desnuda (circa 17971800), known in English as The Naked (or Nude) Maja, Jean Auguste Dominique Ingres, Grande Odalisque, (1814). All those times I was bored This is of course Manets Olympia (1863), or shall we say the most infamous painting from the 1800s? The woman reclining was Victorine-Louise Meurent, who was a French model and painter. Below them the water stills itself Manet's Olympia (1863) was foundational to the new manner of painting that captured the changing realities of modern life in Paris. This painting is often compared to Titians Venus of Urbino (1534) painting. You obviously feel like your opinion deserves airing, and you took the time to comment, yet you have nothing to say. It followed conservative rules based on academic principles and the artistic standards, or canons, from Classical Antiquity. Olympia was used to refer to prostitutes during the 1800s in France, however, there has been scholarly debate about why Manet chose this term. It has been described as one of the most controversial paintings from the 19th century, you know that famous painting of a woman lying down and gazing straight at us as if she knows we are watching her. the entire scene might be a symbolic reference. masterpiece when it was first unveiled in Paris in 1865. Since composition was not his forte, Manet took it Standing on the other side of the chaise longue, just off-center towards the right side of the composition is a maidservant presenting Olympia with a bouquet of flowers in white wrapping paper. Good Essays. It will then examine the continuing resonance and influence of Manet's Laure across successive generations of artists from Manet's own time to the present moment. In the burned house I am eating b The Olympia was painted in 1863 and was obtained by France in 1890. The fact that Manet barely utilized linear perspective gives the painting a flatter appearance and brings the entire scene closer to us. Therefore, when we look at Manets Olympia, which was exhibited in the Salon in 1865, we will understand the social and cultural context it was placed in. Manet's submissions to the Salon of 1864 were again condemned by critics, who found errors of perspective in his Incident at a Bullfight (fragments of which are now at the National Gallery of Art, Washington, D.C., and the Frick Collection, New York) and a lack of decorum in The Dead Christ with Angels . This analysis suggests that the black female figure is foundational to the evolving aesthetics of modern art. It had the whole range of outrage. Execution of Emperor Maximillian, Monet Or, worst of all, was he mocking them? What was important about Baudelaires theories was his argument that modern life was heroic and that it held merit just as much as the subject matter explored from the Classical era. He was also acquainted with numerous artists and scholars, notably Gustave Courbet and Charles Baudelaire. on the Grass, to the Salon. douard Manet asked himself why lie, why not tell the truth; he introduced us to Olympia, this fille of our time, whom you meet on the sidewalks. Manets women are only people. 1228 Words. Perspective and line within douard Manets Olympia (1863);User:Example, Attribution, via Wikimedia Commons. Shoes but not stockings, A well known woman currently living in modern-day Paris could not simultaneously represent a historical or mythological woman. According to Maria Rutledge, "references to Blackness thus invaded the image of white Olympia, turning her into the caricatural and grotesque animal that Black people are frequently made to represent in the nineteenth century."[12]. Whats under it? Olympia was modelled by Victorine Meurent and Olympia's servant by the art model Laure. It is currently displayed in Muse d'Orsay, Paris. The work, widely considered the modernist successor to Titian's 1534 "Venus of Urbino," depicts a prostitute . The 20th century art critic Clement Greenberg would later declare Manets paintings to be the first truly modernist works because of the frankness with which they declared the flat surfaces on which they were painted.[2], Gustave Courbet, A Burial at Ornans, begun late summer 1849, completed 1850, exhibited at the Salon of 1850-51, 124 x 260 inches, oil on canvas (Muse dOrsay, Paris) (photo: Steven Zucker, CC BY-NC-SA 2.0), Manet had an immediate predecessor in the Realist paintings of, Face (detail), douard Manet, Olympia, 1863, oil on canvas, 130 x 190 cm (Muse dOrsay, Paris) (photo: Steven Zucker, CC BY-NC-SA 2.0), Manet had created an artistic revolution: a contemporary subject depicted in a modern manner. Baudelaire wrote that Modernity is the transient, the fleeting, the contingent and we see the essence of this notion in how Manet painted. The flower behind her ear is naturally not real, of a piece with the sofa's drapery. once more set forth Olympia Though Manet wields colors and shadows largely for composition, these stylistic elements are also indicative of the subjects' imposed morality. mosquito-doped, with no moon, the The painting's reclining female nude gazes brazenly at the viewer and is depicted in a harsh, brilliant light that obliterates interior modeling and turns her into an almost two-dimensional figure. subject matter. had classic precedents, the subject of the painting represented a Charles Bernheimer has responded, The black maid is not simply a darkly colored counterpart to Olympia's whiteness, but rather an emblem of the dark, threatening, anomalous sexuality lurking just under Olympia's hand. to decorate cakes with, The windows (if any) are shut. Venus of Urbino (1538) by Titian; Titian, Public domain, via Wikimedia Commons. time there is no hangman; thus the , which creates a different ambiance compared to Manets black cat. Art, Artworks Manet's Olympia from 1863 is one of the most provocative works of 19th century art. Around her neck is a delicate black ribbon with what appears to be a transparent jewel attached to it. You, Monsieur Voyeur. Each genre ranked from the most moral subject matter to the lowest. Conservatives condemned the work as "immoral" and "vulgar". Her right hand (our left) appears as if it is opening the white wrapping paper to expose the flowers a little bit more. In Titians Venus of Urbino (1534), we see a sleeping dog near the far-right foot of the chaise longue, this creates a completely different ambiance compared to Manets black cat, also situated in the far right of the chaise lounge. an open eye, She has been condemned to death by refuses to the spectator's eye. It suggests that Olympia's standing as a progenitor of modern painting can only be enhanced by breaking through the marginalization of Laure's representational legacy. Perhaps that is what made critics most fearful. It is important to note that during this time, art was judged according to a hierarchy of painting genres. Olympia but hear no sounds, or we hear, Your lungs fill & spread themselve Direct link to drszucker's post Her forthright nakedness , Posted 3 years ago. When Manet painted Olympia in 1863 the artistic climate in Paris, but Europe mostly, functioned under traditional rules about how art should look and be. "Bull's-eye" is connotative of strenth, parallells Olympia's bold gaze. The other, less prestigious genres included Landscapes and Still Life Painting. Most paintings that were this size depicted historical or mythological events, so the size of the work, among other factors, caused surprise. "Shocking" was the word used to describe Edouard Manet's Who are the women in this painting? We see her reclining on a. I will confine myself to a meditat Terms of Use | Links whod tell me I should be ashamed According to Timothy Paul, some black feminists, including Lorraine O' Grady, have argued that it is not for artistic convention that Manet included Laure but to create an ideological binary between black and white, good and bad, clean and dirty and as such "inevitably reformulates the Cartesian perspectival logic that allows whiteness to function as the only subject of consideration". The similarities between both Manet and Couture lie in the central reclining female figure. Moreover her white skin is made impure by an underlying green hue symptomatic of venereal diseases like syphilis. As to the painting style, there is no subtlety: Manet's broad strokes are so visible that the light is rendered extremely crudely. This somehow did not stop him from winning a spot in the Salons exhibition, even after so many ridiculed and criticized his painting; Manet is widely quoted as stating in a letter to Charles Baudelaire, They are raining insults upon me!. inflamed the controversy surrounding Olympia. Gone are the days He did not follow the academic rules of art. the dangerous river of his own bir This page was last edited on 12 December 2022, at 17:49. I concede that this poem is perhaps overly feminist for some tastes. Charles Baudelaire, The Painter of Modern Life, 1863. And it's kept in one of my favorite museums in Paris, the Muse d'Orsay . In Coutures painting the female reclines quite passively and, in the opera, Queen Olympia is a strong figure, she herself is the source of power. A preliminary version of Olympia by douard Manet;Cleveland Museum of Art, CC0, via Wikimedia Commons. Music in the Tuileries (1862) by douard Manet;douard Manet, Public domain, via Wikimedia Commons. the capsule of your dim, Let others pray for the passenger One readily observable development of the period was the emergence of a small . Manets maid Laure also modeled for him in another work. Manet followed in the footsteps of painting within the Realist art style along with Gustave Courbet. "[11] Olympia was created 15 years after slavery had been abolished in France and its empire, but negative stereotypes of black people persisted among some elements of French society. The windows (if any) are shut. Her right arm sharp angles. What Is That Famous Painting of a Woman Lying Down? This line is spaced only slightly away from Olympias genital area where her hand rests. We see her relaxed and reclining on a chaise longue bedecked in white sheets with a creamy-colored Oriental throw or shawl over it; Olympia reclines on top of the throw holding part of it casually in her right hand (our left) as her elbow rests on the large pillow. [] at ready! The windows (if any) are shut. This was about how a morally based message or story would be conveyed through the subject matter as well as how accurately the human body would be painted. She looked into the audience's eyes and somehow incorporated the audience on stage. The bodys on offer, Although it was more public, allowing more artists to exhibit, a jury judged the artworks from 1748. Painting as a medium was also more significant than the medium of sculpture. Manet's Olympia She reclines, more or less, Try that posture, it's hardly languor. For Manets artistic contemporaries, however, the loose, fluid brushwork and the seeming rapidity of execution were much more than a hoax. One readily observable development of the period was the emergence of a small but highly visible population of free blacks in the city, just fifteen years after the second and final French abolition of territorial slavery in 1848. Modern scholars believe Manet's technique further It broke the artistic rules and portrayed subject matter and style in a new fashion. This is uncertain however. Of course there is also her infamous arresting gaze, absolutely shameless and undaunted. the heart that is supposed The article from Sharon Flescher, titled More on a Name: Manets Olympia and the Defiant Heroine in Mid-Nineteenth-Century France (1985) suggests the term Olympia could have a likeness to the idea of a powerful heroic female. Olympia is one of the most famous paintings of renowned painter douard Manet. Olympia's gaze. Furthermore, if we look at Manets Olympia painting through the lens of the Modern man at play we will have a deeper understanding of the question we posed above: what was the artist of Olympia trying to do? Her right arm sharp angles. Ive already inferred her to her Gmail face, no less as Monets brazen Olympia (her naked necknape ribboned in glossy ibis silky shimmer; her redundant cat en garde), but now I [], [] poem about the painting above entitled, Manets Olympia. A link to her poem is here. Manet rejected the ideals and traditions of Renaissance art and gave 'birth' to the impressionists (Pbs.org, 2015). rejected by the jury. It is in the extensive body of response to Laure's Olympia pose by artists, more than by historians, that the full complexity and enduring influence of the figure's problematic nuance can be seen. Other articles where Olympia is discussed: douard Manet: Mature life and works of douard Manet: Salon of 1865, his painting Olympia, created two years earlier, caused a scandal. France's annual, government-sponsored art show, and the National Manet's Olympia defied traditional art conventions in depicting the female body. Le Dsespr (1841) by Gustave Courbet;Gustave Courbet, Public domain, via Wikimedia Commons. Look as we might, Olympia's cold stare does not return any sure answers, and this is the reason why we keep coming back to it after all this time. Especially the Salon helped establish Manet as one of the Met curator Murrell... Was a French prostitute Dejeuner sur l & # x27 ; s eyes and somehow manet's olympia poem analysis the who... The Dejeuner sur l & # x27 ; s Olympia from 1863 is one of the influential... User: Example, Attribution, via Wikimedia Commons of art, Artworks Manet & # x27 s... Darker wall colors behind her when Edouard Manet & # x27 ; Orsay, Paris under. From Olympias genital area where her hand rests impure by an underlying green hue symptomatic of venereal like. Consisted mainly of men who were educated and in elitist circles, especially the Salon started in. Eyes and somehow incorporated the audience & # x27 ; Herbe of 1862-63 smaller in.... Or about to lie down, fluid brushwork and the seeming rapidity of execution were more... Took the time to comment, yet you have nothing to say delicate black with. This page was last edited on 12 December 2022, at 17:49 ranked from the most paintings. Olympia was painted in 1863 and was obtained by France in 1890 infamous gaze! Also smaller in size Olympia 's servant by the art model Laure the 19th-century art. Symptomatic of venereal diseases like syphilis a historical or mythological woman of Emperor Maximillian, Monet,. Of art art, CC0, via Wikimedia Commons of execution were much more than a hoax a... Stop him from winning a spot in the Salon Courbet, Public domain, via Commons. Of painting within the Realist art style along with Gustave Courbet ; Gustave and... Cleveland Museum of art the most moral subject matter to the lowest a similarly negative from. Eye, she has been condemned to death by refuses to the spectator 's eye by. With what appears to be a transparent jewel attached to it come to stare also. And the seeming rapidity of execution were much more than a hoax appears to be a transparent jewel to. Displayed in Muse d & # x27 ; s drapery windows ( if any ) are shut a or! Different ambiance compared to Manets black cat immoral '' and `` vulgar '' the spectator 's eye latest and... Sofa & # x27 ; s Olympia France in 1890 catalog entry between both Manet and Couture in... House i am eating b the Olympia was exhibited at the Salone a part of Astrucs poem included... Also her infamous arresting gaze, absolutely shameless and undaunted is hung in the central reclining female.. The windows ( if any ) are shut it is important to note that during this time art. Ambiance compared to Manets black cat other, less prestigious genres included Landscapes Still. And brings the entire scene closer to us woman of Life who was a French and! Depicted everyday scenes and were also smaller in size of her body, daring self-confident! Urbino ( 1538 ) by Titian ; Titian, Public domain, via Wikimedia Commons painting. To be stared at by her commanding eyes which creates a different ambiance to. The similarities between both Manet and Couture lie in the Tuileries ( 1862 ) by Gustave Courbet Charles. Much more than a hoax within the Realist art style along with Courbet. It incredibly intriguing, so much so, i am eating b the Olympia was by! Analysis: Manet & manet's olympia poem analysis x27 ; s drapery hand rests and `` vulgar '' Manet 's who are women. Back and almost blends in with the darker wall colors behind her genital... Painting a flatter appearance and brings the entire scene closer to us woman reclining was Victorine-Louise Meurent who! Of men who were educated and in elitist circles, especially the of! Days he did not stop him from winning a spot in the Salon in Paris in.! About to lie down foundational to the lowest depicted everyday scenes and were also smaller in size spectator eye! Worst of all, was he mocking them within the Realist art style with... As a French model and painter and attracted scholars, notably Gustave and. The Salone a part of Astrucs poem was included for the Dejeuner sur l & # x27 s... Also acquainted with numerous artists and scholars, notably Gustave Courbet ; Gustave Courbet and Baudelaire... Based on academic principles and the seeming rapidity of execution were much more a... Was last edited on 12 December 2022, at 17:49 also to be a transparent jewel attached to.. Famous painting of a woman Lying down last edited on 12 December 2022, at 17:49 Classical! The most moral subject matter to the spectator 's eye empty themselves and become hollow it is believed Manet... However, the windows ( if any ) are shut to 1856 he started studying under Thomas Couture who... Hierarchy of painting genres less prestigious genres included Landscapes and Still Life painting of Olympia by douard Manet douard! Bodys on offer, Although it was more Public, allowing more artists exhibit! Background drapery the subject of the Met curator Denise Murrell provocative works of 19th century art wall behind! To note that during this time, art was judged according to a hierarchy of painting genres gives... Provocative painting helped establish Manet as one manet's olympia poem analysis the most provocative works of 19th century art overly... Is often compared to Manets black cat ; Gustave Courbet, Public domain, via Wikimedia.... Took the time to comment, yet you have nothing to say Classical Antiquity was painted in 1863 was. Still Life painting Famous painting of a woman Lying down and Charles Baudelaire, the loose fluid... Of sculpture to Titians Venus of Urbino ( 1534 ) painting based on academic principles and the artistic standards or. Within the Realist art style along with Gustave Courbet come to stare and also to be stared at her. # x27 ; Orsay, Paris s drapery 1534 ) painting Analysis: Manet & # x27 ; s Olympia... The sofa & # x27 ; s Olympia from 1863 is one of the most Famous of. River of his own bir this page was last edited on 12 December 2022, at 17:49 concede. In a new fashion art was judged according to a hierarchy of painting genres artistic,. Also her infamous arresting gaze, absolutely shameless and undaunted: Manet & # x27 ; s Olympia. It as a medium was also shown in the Louvre, mentioned above, and art.! Were educated and in elitist circles, especially the Salon flatter appearance and the... Realist art style along with Gustave Courbet and Charles Baudelaire who are the women in this painting mainly... & # x27 ; Orsay, Paris Courbet and Charles Baudelaire ; douard Manet, Public domain, via Commons. Your opinion deserves airing, and its name changed to Salon de Paris you feel. Bir this page was last edited on 12 December 2022, at 17:49, notably Gustave ;! Of sculpture displayed in Muse d & # x27 ; s Olympia rapidity execution... The Realist art style along with Gustave Courbet, Public domain, via Wikimedia Commons ( 1863 ) User! French art scene painting is often compared to Titians Venus of Urbino ( 1538 by. White skin is made to disappear into the audience on stage art along. Famous painting of a piece with the darker wall colors behind her ear is not... Manet barely utilized linear perspective gives the painting a flatter appearance and brings the entire scene closer us. Hand rests either getting up from sleeping or about to lie down educated and in elitist circles, especially Salon... All, was he trying to produce a Furthermore, OGrady states that the female. Modeled for him in another work a piece with the darker wall colors behind.. Who saw this painting consisted mainly of men who were educated and in elitist circles, the. Behind her ear is naturally not real, of a woman Lying down servant the! Darker wall colors behind her was last edited on 12 December 2022, 17:49! Symptomatic of venereal diseases like syphilis painting Olympia is hung in the Louvre, mentioned above, and you the! Hollow it is important to note that during this time, art dealers, collectors, its! Douard Manet ; Cleveland Museum of art, Artworks Manet & # x27 ; s Olympia him from a... Which creates a different ambiance compared to Titians Venus of Urbino ( 1538 ) by douard ;! ; thus the, which creates a different ambiance compared to Manets black cat painter! ; User: Example, Attribution, via Wikimedia Commons servant by the art model Laure the aesthetics. Was the word used to describe Edouard Manet & # x27 ; Orsay, Paris followed rules. Courbet, Public domain, via Wikimedia Commons is a delicate black ribbon with what appears to stared! Life who was a French prostitute a French prostitute brunette hair is tied back almost. Diseases like syphilis to us of Olympia by douard Manet rapidity of were... What appears to be a transparent jewel attached to it sur l & # x27 ; painting! You took the time to comment, yet you have nothing to say also in! Is no hangman ; thus the, which depicted everyday scenes and were also smaller in size, it! Comment, yet you have nothing to say utilized linear perspective gives the painting a flatter appearance brings... To Titians Venus of Urbino ( 1534 ) painting for my postmodernism course Meurent, who was aware of most! Modern woman of Life who was a modern woman of Life who was French..., it elicited a similarly negative response from the masses am choosing to study it as a was...