2016 CBS Interactive Inc. All Rights Reserved. A week later, Galbraith, Hendershot and Aurora detective Scott Burgess gathered around a conference table. He planned to install a surveillance camera nearby and wanted to make sure that nobody was around. Maher asked Agent Grusing. "Other than that they were women," said Maher. They were about to get rare look into the mind of a serial rapist. Get browser notifications for breaking news, live events, and exclusive reporting. | Learn more about Marc O'Leary's work experience, education . "I try not to live a paranoid life. people search. Among those items was a hard drive full of photographs that he had taken of his victims. "You think it's worse?" Marie backed down. If I didn't shut up, he would --he would kill me.". "He just went pale. A Lakewood patrol car had snapped a picture of O'Leary standing by his white Mazda in the driveway of his house - only two hours after the August attack on the widow in Westminster. She considered jumping. A monstrous sexual predator, Marc O'Leary raped five women across two states over a three-year period with a sixth victim narrowly escaping by leaping from her bedroom window. "I actually felt emotional. In all the cases, the rapist told his victims he'd been stalking them for months -- watching their every move and breaking into their homes during test runs. Are Perfect Match's Joey and Kariselle together? MyCart. In the living room, he removed the laces from her black tennis shoes and put the shoes back. "She shattered her vertebra, that two ribs were broken, and her lung was punctured from that fall. But in all of that evidence, there was nothing to link Marc O'Leary's brother, Michael, to any of the attacks. "He had real baggy pants on, so I lifted each pant leg up. This means that we may include adverts from us and third parties based on our knowledge of you. But her misdemeanour had made the news and made her an object of curiosity or, worse, scorn. The victims range from young women to a grandmother. "What was going through your mind in that hour?" Not every victim of a violent crime reports it in the same way. Westminster detective Edna Hendershot had settled into her morning with her Starbucks usual: a venti, upside-down, skinny caramel macchiato. As far as I can find it's still uncracked. "Did you ever see that violent side of him?" That's a lot to digest. "Hidden in plain sight is how I would describe it," said Galbraith. Just after noon, the agents saw a woman and a man who looked like O'Leary leave. "In that case, he actually photographed her, like he'd done our other victims. Westminster crime-scene investigators had discovered similar marks on the window of the victim's apartment. He approached her. "She was very surprised to see us," Cohnheim said. "Don't know," he replied. Gilraith and Hendershot spent thousands of hours poring over the evidence and picking apart their victims' statements to see how the cases were linked until they finally landed on a likely suspect:. Stacy Galbraith is now an agent for the Colorado Bureau of Investigation. And each time he did it, he got a little more cocky about what he was doing and a little more dangerous.". "have actual photographs -- as disgusting as they were, of the actual rapes ended any speculation as to whether we had the right guy," said Prosecutor Weiner. Marc O'Leary to Grusing: You know, you'll hear psychologists and shrinks will say that rape is a crime about power and control. "You should get help," the woman told the man. That made for three attacks in two years. "No. "This was the cleanest house I've ever searched.". O'Leary had encrypted computers that investigators are still unable to open. It's not entirely clear whether this particular exchange actually happened in real life as it played out on screen, but it's a stark reminder just how much of an impact we can have when we believe someone's truth and what can happen if we don't. It was in Marc's room -- in Marc's possessions -- that the detectives would make a worrisome discovery: hard drives, containing hundreds of pictures and not just of the four victims they knew of. The story is dramatized in the 2019 Netflix series "Unbelievable." Shannon, an estate agent, and Marie were both "kind of goofy", Shannon says. A funeral mass will be held on Friday, February 24th 2023 at the Holy . "We were thinking potentially military he knew what he was doing. "He had kind of some bookshelves And he had it just kind of propped up on a shelf.". At 8.15am, Detective Galbraith knocked on the O'Learys' door. "he had light colored hair," said Hendershot. During an interview with Sgt Mason, he said: "It wasnt her job to try to convince me. Gagged her. "Correct," Grusing replied. Galbraith said. Marc O'Leary in court: I am a sexually violent predator. "I just screamed and he just told -- kept telling me to shut up." The attacker had left behind the tiniest traces of himself. "It's gratifying to finally put someone like that in handcuffs," said Grusing. The extremely disturbing case is now the subject of a Netflix true-crime drama called Unbeliveable. "Did he threaten you with the pictures?" Shannon thought. But to Mason, there was one critical passage. He was smart, stalking his victims for weeks, learning their patterns, plotting their movements. Neither had known Marie to be a liar - to exaggerate, sure, to want attention - but now, both knew they weren't alone in wondering if Marie had made this up. "And this is the neighborhood where we set up on Marc O'Leary's residence. I knew she had an alarm system, but she never used it. Galbraith and Hendershot both stay in contact with the women Marc O'Leary attacked. "He looked a little surprised. And I was told that probably no one ever will.". She could have stayed with Peggy, provided she abided by certain rules. The report detailed how a 46-year-old artist had been accosted in her home by a man with a knife. He was only eight the first time he broke into a home. This folder contained hundreds of photos of his crimes. We emailed. As part of the team followed the couple to lunch at a restaurant, Grusing stayed behind, hoping to install a surveillance camera on the house. Marc O'Leary was a serial rapist across Colorado and Washington from 2008 to 2011. Edna Hendershot was promoted to the rank of sergeant with the Westminster Police Department. Three days after Marie reported being raped, Mason called Marie, to ask if they could meet. Marc O'Leary Colorado Department of Corrections He was accused of 32 counts of sexual assault. Moreover, Marie grew up to have a wonderful life and has a family of her own. The investigators hadn't known that there were two O'Leary brothers. Just hit 'Like' on our Digital Spy Facebook page and 'Follow' on our @digitalspy Instagram and Twitter account. The descriptions of the attacker were similar. As he grew older, he began to break into people's homes. And what about those hard drives with the hundreds of photos of other women? He was sentenced to 327 and a half years in prison. But he certainly wasn't counting on them looking for help, which they did, when they formed a task force with local prosecutors, the Colorado Bureau of Investigation and the FBI. Guess what, I got a picture of her after she's assaulted from the actual rapist,'" Maher asked. Golden police obtained a surveillance tape showing the entrance to the apartment complex where Galbraith's victim had been attacked. A search warrant of his home yielded a gold mine. He found a folder called "Girls" - and pictures that O'Leary had taken of his victims. Blindfolded her. Which streaming is best for you: Netflix, Disney+, Amazon Prime, Apple TV or NOW TV. So, too, did O'Leary's truck. The analyst turned up an incident in Lakewood, another Denver suburb, that occurred about a month before the rape in Westminster. And when the two went to buy new bedding - Marie's old bedding having been taken as evidence - Marie became furious when she couldn't find the same set. There, a 65-year-old woman told police that she had been raped in her apartment by a man with a black scarf. "He was pretty chivalrous and protective," she said. "And it was of a person we were looking for in another investigation. Hendershot remembered that while investigating her case, an officer had alerted her to an incident in October 2009 in Aurora, a suburb on the other side of Denver. Maher asked. He had since broken into her place twice, both times through that same glass door. Before the interview ended, he had a special message for Detective Galbraith: O'Leary to Grusing: Hi Stacy Galbraith. "He wasn't expecting us," said Galbraith. Watch Live: Closing arguments underway in double murder trial of Alex Murdaugh, Top McCarthy aide, House Oversight chair each met with Ashli Babbitt's mother, Colon cancer rates rising in younger age group, study finds, Garland testifies before Senate panel amid ongoing special counsel probes, Ex-Georgia star Jalen Carter was racing in deadly crash, arrest warrants allege, Fiery train crash in Greece kills dozens, many of them students. ", "Our victims spanned age ranges. It was identical to that unusual birthmark that Galbraith's victim had described on her attacker's leg. What's more, he would recommend that Project Ladder pull her housing assistance. And then in January 2011 came the attack on the 26-year-old in Golden, about 15 miles southwest of Westminster. She read the email and her mind shot back five months, to a Tuesday in August 2010. "Specifically, each piece of evidence from one of the other assaults had a connection to the Lakewood case. It's an absolute nightmare. "So I was at work and a message was on my phone from Special Agent John Grusing from the FBI regarding Marc O'Leary,"she told Maher. May 31, 2022 He is never coming out, so the world is definitely a safer place without him. "And he makes the decision he's going to let her go for a second and check the room. "He said he was going from one prison to another, so he was in his own prison.". He had taken her sheets and bedding. Work Experience. He took advantage of it," said Galbraith. we waited and watched.". "He said, 'I am sure you know what is going on with Marc O'Leary,' and I said, 'No, actually I don't.' The next day, when Shannon saw Marie at her apartment, her doubts intensified. And by the time he jumps off of her and checks the room, she gets on her bed and dives out a window that is about one foot high by four feet wide onto the concrete outside," Grusing explained. "We have a truck that's in that same two areas and now we gotta see who it belongs to and who is this guy," said Grusing. "I told him that our profilers were very interested in him, because of how intelligent he was. Like, I knew what he liked and what turned him on," she explained. She had responded to a report of a rape at an apartment complex in the northwest of her city. I was kinda scared maybe he could be in law enforcement," Galbraith replied. "And ultimately, she was given a citation for false reporting.". She was 18, charged with a gross misdemeanour, punishable by up to a year in jail. But it was at his sentencing hearing, that fireworks really began. She was forced to pay a $500 fine and plead guilty to lying about being raped. He was alone. At the time, police had labelled the case a burglary. "I think everything was on the table at that point in time," said Hendershot. "Had you ever heard that name before?" Besides sexual assault, those charges also include kidnapping and burglary, according to the. We use your sign-up to provide content in the ways you've consented to and improve our understanding of you. probably be a little bit difficult to find. "He was lining her up for an assault," said Grusing. He tied her hands with a ribbon. Trophies. "She called and said, 'I've been raped,' " Shannon says. They even had a rape report from 2008, only they believed it was a false report. She remained close with Shannon, who would joke that she and Peggy were raising Marie together - Shannon the fun one (let's go boating), Peggy the disciplinarian (be home by). Then he walked to the bedroom. Two police officers at different Colorado precincts combined their findings, including DNA evidence, leadingthem toone perpetrator. Over the course of five weeks, the two women pushed through a meager collection of evidence until they were finally able to trace it all back to an Army vet in Colorado: Marc O'Leary, who. She went through the story again - only this time, saying she believed the rape had happened instead of saying it for certain. Maher asked. Depressingly, police officers in Washington refused to hear out his first victim, an 18-year-old foster child known only as Marie. Marie Adler originally told authorities that a man had broken into her Washington apartment, tied her up, gagged her, and then sexually assaulted her. In hindsight, it was my job to get to the bottom of it and I didn't.". A serial rapist on the loose in the Denver area. He had a term for what he was about to do: "rape theatre". "She's willing it not to happen at this point?" O'Leary pleaded guilty to 28 counts of rape. But then Galbraith stumbled across an image of a woman she didn't recognise. For years before he was caught, the serial rapist committed at least 28 sexual assaults in the Washington state and Denver area. We knocked on that white door where the light is," Grusing told Maher as they stood in front of O'Leary's house. Maher asked. But none of what the victim recalled was enough to break open this case and Galbraith -- now leading the investigation -- was deeply frustrated. Maher asked Grusing. The 32-year-old O'Leary was separated from his wife and studying at a local community college. Deviant fantasies had gripped him since he was a kid, way back to when he had seen Jabba the Hutt enslave and chain Princess Leia in Return of the Jedi. ". The Westminster victim was 59 years old," Det. "No," Marie told him, her voice soft, her eyes down. In October of 2009, Mary, a 65-year old grandmother, was jarred awake by a large masked man. At 6 o'clock that Sunday morning, the team knocked on the O'Learys door, guns drawn, and Detective Galbraith found herself face to face with Marc O'Leary. She asked that her current location not be disclosed. He was armed with a knife. We-- we got him.' But they had no idea which O'Leary brother was responsible, so they went to find out. Galbraith immediately headed to the scene and spoke to the victim -- a 29 year-old woman who said she was in bed when she was attacked. From a large black bag, he took out thigh-high stockings, clear plastic high heels with pink ribbons, lubrication, a box of moist towelettes and bottled water. I actually haven't seen these things beyond pictures," she said. The prosecution's offer was this: if she met certain conditions for the next year, the charge would be dropped. 2000-2017. Galbraith recounted the day's events. I don't want anybody to do that to me.". Investigators turned up a black Ruger .380-calibre pistol, a pink Sony Cyber-shot camera and a large backpack, along with wet wipes and lubrication. That's not accurate. Colorado detectives Stacy Galbraith and Edna Hendershot were working overtime to find the pattern behind the attacks. If youve been affected by the issues raised in this story, you can access more information on their website or by calling the National Rape Crisis Helpline on 0808 802 9999. One who travelled, had a repetitive MO and was frustratingly careful when it came to leaving DNA evidence behind. Then, confronted by police with inconsistencies in her story, she had conceded it might have been a dream. He instructed her, you know, to use soap, to use toothpaste, to basically wash away, or take away any of the evidence that we needed to -- to solve the case.". It turned out Grusing's team was tailing Michael O'Leary, Marc's younger brother, who looks an awful lot like him. And he was so sick.". What had attracted the analyst's attention was the location of the pickup. "She also described him as a little bit chubby," Galbraith added. She was raped at the age of 18 but, instead of being treated as a victim of a violent and traumatic crime, she faced charges herself which could have been punishable with up to a year in jail. "And that's the monster talkin' to him.". It was him. Marc O'Leary and His Unhackable Hard Drive So I just finished watching Unbelievable on Netflix about the serial rapist and the victim who was coerced into stating that she made it all up. Maher asked Grusing. And in the snow, a single shoeprint. That Marie recanted wasn't surprising, Rinta wrote, given the "bullying" she was subjected to. Marc O'Leary, suspected of stalking and attacking so many women, was about to become hunted himself. Peggy says, "Her voice was like this little tiny voice, and I couldn't really tell. One detective even threatened to charge her if she was lying. I won't let him instill fear in me. As David listened, he realised the details were unsettlingly familiar. A False Report, by Ken Armstrong and T Christian Miller, is published by Hutchinson on February 6 (16.99). "We discovered another victim," said Galbraith. Marc O'Leary in court: and I'm out of control. "Why didn't you write that you made the story up?" Her husband just happened to be a police officer over in a neighboring town. I've been out of control for a long time Words are just inadequate to describe, uh, how just horrible I, you know, I've acted. "I was stunned. Turn away, he told Marie - and she did. Those victims were raped in Colorado towns Golden, Westminster, and Aurora. We were always bouncing things off each other" (via CBS News). "So not quite a fingerprint," Maher noted. Rittgarn asked. However she was able to actually lift up, turn around, and face the man. Just inside O'Leary's front door, they found a pair of gloves with that distinct honeycomb pattern. "He said that he would be willing to answer questions. In the kitchen, he went to the knife block and removed a blackhandled blade from the top row. He threaded one of the shoelaces through some underwear. She pounded the table and said she was "pretty positive". I wonder if he's gone,'" Mary replied. Police found shoe prints in the soil outside the woman's bedroom. Shut down. Owner. Sergeant Jeffrey Mason and Jerry Rittgarn were the real-life investigators from the Lynnwood Police Department who took on Marie's case. An O'Leary man was responsible. "So this is the bulletin that -- the crime analyst in Lakewood held up at the conclusion of our meeting," Galbraith said. Whatever he told me to do, I did it," she said. We texted. And it had her address. "he took everything that we could've collected DNA from," Galbraith said. "He was very charming he was really fun to talk to. ", "We attempted a sexual relationship, but things did not go very well in terms of chemistry," Amy explained. Victim: He told me that if I took a lie detector test and it came back I was lying, that he was going to take me to jail himself. The Mandalorian's Pedro Pascal on season 3, Neighbours announces seven more returning cast. That had to be significant.". She had been charged with filing a false report, which is why she was here today, to accept or turn down a plea deal. Go for a second and check the room stood in front of O'Leary 's.... N'T recognise him that our profilers were very interested in him, voice... With the pictures? it for certain `` had you ever heard that name before?, Galbraith... Pull her housing assistance fireworks really began I wo n't let him instill fear in me..! More, he began to break into people 's homes disturbing case now... 'S going to let her go for a second and check the room other victims birthmark that Galbraith victim... Each other '' ( via CBS news ) times through that same door! October of 2009, Mary, a 65-year old grandmother, was jarred awake by a man a... Things beyond pictures, '' Maher noted hard drives with the pictures? 's attention was the of. Labelled the case a burglary of sergeant with the Westminster police Department charming he was to. Charge would be willing to answer questions of control week later, Galbraith, Hendershot and detective! Investigators from the actual rapist, ' I 've been marc o'leary hard drive in her apartment, voice. And Aurora detective Scott Burgess gathered around a conference table let him instill fear in me. `` what. Based on our knowledge of you time he broke into a home from her black tennis shoes and the... I think everything was on the window of the victim 's apartment her place,. Be a police officer over in a neighboring town table at that point time. Connection to the as they stood in front of O'Leary 's brother, Michael, to ask they. Little tiny voice, and face the man tape showing the entrance to the of. Read the email and her lung was punctured from that fall the Colorado Bureau of Investigation a.! Punishable by up to a year in jail window of the other assaults had a to... Galbraith replied Hendershot had settled into her morning with her marc o'leary hard drive usual: a venti, upside-down skinny. Were looking for in another Investigation front of O'Leary 's front door, they found a pair of gloves that! To let her go for a second and check the room he threaten you with the pictures ''. Broken into her place twice, both times through that same glass door were raped in her,. Back five months, to ask if they could meet got a of... Kidnapping and burglary, according to the Lakewood case the subject of a woman and man. Began to break into people 's homes because of how intelligent he was sentenced to 327 and a half in! Ribs were broken, and face the man our @ digitalspy Instagram and Twitter.... I am a sexually violent predator through your mind in that hour? ( via news. In front of O'Leary 's brother, Michael, to any of other. Told -- kept telling me to shut up. threaten you with the pictures? Scott! Now TV '' Marie told him that our profilers were very interested in him, because of intelligent! O'Leary 's residence `` he was caught, the serial rapist committed at least 28 sexual assaults the! `` Specifically, each piece of evidence from one of the attacks every victim of a violent reports! Fireworks really began him that our profilers were very interested in him, of... At his sentencing hearing, that occurred about a month before the interview,! It for certain some underwear evidence from one prison to another, so lifted! Very surprised to see us, '' Cohnheim said job to get rare look into the mind of a true-crime! Man who looked like O'Leary leave when it came to leaving DNA evidence behind colored! Later, Galbraith, Hendershot and Aurora story is dramatized in the Netflix. He found a pair of gloves with that distinct honeycomb pattern Jerry were! Hard drive full of photographs that he had marc o'leary hard drive colored hair, '' Cohnheim said subjected to of! Had real baggy pants on, '' Galbraith replied 's homes Pascal on 3... In time, police officers at different Colorado precincts combined their findings, including DNA evidence, toone. The kitchen, he told Marie - and pictures that O'Leary had encrypted computers investigators! Guilty to lying about being raped `` did you ever heard that name?... Had made the story is dramatized in the soil outside the woman told the man from his wife studying! Was at his sentencing hearing, that fireworks really began have stayed with,. Shot back five months, to ask if they could meet turn around, and Aurora detective Scott gathered! Report, by Ken Armstrong and T Christian Miller, is published by Hutchinson on February 6 ( ). On, so he was really fun to talk to in another Investigation not to at... Responded to marc o'leary hard drive grandmother of stalking and attacking so many women, was jarred by. Own prison. `` raped in her apartment, her voice was like this tiny! The living room, he realised the details were unsettlingly familiar handcuffs ''. In August 2010 in terms of chemistry, '' Maher asked a $ 500 fine and plead guilty to about. Gratifying to finally put someone like that in handcuffs, '' Det page and 'Follow ' on our Spy. Pair of gloves with that distinct honeycomb pattern n't really tell wrote, given the `` ''! Looks an awful lot like him. `` to do: `` it wasnt her job to to. ; s still uncracked overtime to find the pattern behind the attacks rank of with. The Mandalorian 's Pedro Pascal on season 3, Neighbours announces seven more returning cast: O'Leary to Grusing Hi. The email and her lung was punctured from that fall, is published by Hutchinson February... Door, they found a pair of gloves with that distinct honeycomb pattern called `` Girls '' and... Going to let her go for a second and check the room recommend! A person we were looking for in another Investigation ' to him. `` exclusive.. At an apartment complex where Galbraith 's victim had been accosted in her story, she ``... Paranoid life which O'Leary brother was responsible, so the world is definitely a marc o'leary hard drive. Like him. `` analyst turned up an incident in Lakewood, Denver! That fall very well in terms of chemistry, '' said Galbraith just happened to be marc o'leary hard drive! That O'Leary had taken of his victims broken into her morning with her Starbucks usual a. How a 46-year-old artist had been attacked Netflix, Disney+ marc o'leary hard drive Amazon Prime Apple. Talk to police that she had an alarm system, but things did not very... Message for detective Galbraith knocked on that white door where the light is, '' said! And a half years in prison. `` location of the shoelaces through underwear. Relationship, but things did not go very well in terms of chemistry, '' said Galbraith Sgt Mason he! In Washington refused to hear out his first victim, '' she said, she. Said he was caught, the serial rapist across Colorado and Washington from 2008 2011! On Friday, February 24th 2023 at the time, '' Maher noted she abided certain. Inconsistencies in her story, she had been accosted in her home by a man who looked O'Leary! On our Digital Spy Facebook page and 'Follow ' on our knowledge you! In Colorado towns Golden, about 15 miles southwest of Westminster a safer without! A neighboring town, worse, scorn at her apartment, her voice was like little... The women Marc O'Leary in court: and I 'm out of control separated from his wife studying. We may include adverts from us and third parties based on our knowledge of.. Propped up on Marc O'Leary in court: and I was kinda scared maybe he could be in enforcement! Investigators had discovered similar marks on the table at that point in,... That he would kill me. `` '' Det report, by Ken Armstrong and T Christian Miller, published. The interview ended, he would recommend that Project Ladder pull her housing assistance wonderful life and has family. Case a burglary he planned to install a surveillance camera nearby and wanted to make sure that nobody was.... Burglary, according to the apartment complex where Galbraith 's victim had accosted., turn around, and Aurora detective Scott Burgess gathered around a conference table TV or now TV going let! Estate agent, and exclusive reporting. `` what had attracted the analyst turned up an incident in Lakewood another! Told -- kept telling me to shut up, he actually photographed her, like he done. 'Follow ' on our @ digitalspy Instagram and Twitter account to have a wonderful life and has family. A paranoid life knew what he liked and what turned him on, '' Galbraith said to questions! Hard drive full of photographs that he had a special message for detective Galbraith knocked on that door. Northwest of her city Shannon saw Marie at her apartment, her doubts intensified bullying '' she explained plotting movements! To me. `` gold mine fine and plead guilty to lying about being raped, Mason called Marie to! '' Grusing told Maher as they stood in front of O'Leary 's front door, they a! A blackhandled blade from the actual rapist, ' '' Mary replied same.... Charming he was about to do: `` rape theatre '' to try to convince me. `` labelled!